Recently I read a newspaper article preoccupied with the Pope using an expensive car (a Mercedes), a pair of red leather shoes, and what the article’s writer called the spectacle of the recent Brother Andre celebration in Montreal. The main point was chastising the Church for spending on what appears to be luxury items when there are so many people in need. After hitting on ‘the wealth of the Church, the article then made reference to pedophile priests, a subject often re-visited by this writer. So, I thought a few more details might offer a more complete perspective around the topics raised, trying to see the whole Church rather than just select pieces.
The issue of pedophile priests is a truly horrific situation, and the initial handling of these crimes by Church authorities can only be called incompetent. Much has been done since those early days to un-earth, expose and eliminate both the perpetrators and the problem, and to make amends. It is accurate to say more still needs to be done. That said there are some 400,000 priests worldwide who have not been implicated nor charged of any crime, this one or any other. These men dedicate their entire lives to the support, care and betterment of others in virtually every situation. I’ve had the good fortune to know a few of these priests, and can attest the people they impact in a positive way is more than I can measure.
Priests accused of crimes are now relieved of church duties until such time as they have been judged by the evidence in a court of law, a now standard practice. For me it is equally important I respect the precept of innocent until proven guilty while any investigation and legal process occurs. Finally, I am most passionate about ensuring I’m not drawn into guilt-by-association thinking; that others priests may be guilty of misdeeds simply because of a shared vocation.
Shifting to look under the umbrella of money, I find it useful to look at a few programs on which the Church does spend a lot of money:
· The Catholic Church has 3,500,000 teachers in 250,000 Catholic schools worldwide, teaching some 42,000,000 pupils, many in countries where no other organization operates such services
· The Church is the largest single educational institution worldwide by an order of magnitude over the next largest, with 213 Catholic universities and colleges in the US alone.
· This same Church is also the largest operator of hospitals worldwide (by a staggering margin)
· In the US, it has 585 hospitals serving 84,000,000 patients, an number that increases exponentially when world figures are taken into account
· The Catholic Church is the largest charitable organization in the world, again by an stunningly large margin
I could go on. But it is against these statistics the newspaper article complains about the brand of car and shoes the Pope uses. I suggest the article author may be more preoccupied with creating a negative impression rather than seeing the larger picture. Examining just one of the writer’s issues, the Pope’s car must be bullet-proof for obvious reasons, a feature offered only on vehicles in higher-end categories (such as Mercedes).
The Church’s finances have come up before, from this writer and others. And if you’ve ever had an opportunity to visit the Vatican Museum in Rome, it is easy to get the impression of great wealth. Fabulous art, paintings and tapestries adorn hallway after gallery after display. The Sistine Chapel alone contains priceless works on walls and ceilings. Add to this the building and property value of thousands of churches virtually everywhere, many in prime, big city locations, and there are indeed a lot of assets to be considered.
For much of the art, with paintings such as those from Michael Angelo, antiquity alone has dramatically increased their commercial value, especially in our modern world of so many collectors. What seems to be misunderstood is that a great many of these works were presented to the Church as gifts to God. They were offered up by individuals who wished to thank God for the talent and circumstances enjoyed during an earthly life blessed with plenty. As such, the Church is less an owner of these artifacts, and more a minder of them, obliged to maintain the offerings as the gifts they were intended to be. Value does not in any way alter the duty of the Church to preserve these treasures for generations and centuries to come.
As to church buildings and properties, in most cases each was built through the sweat and donations and fund raising of a local community, often from decades and centuries gone by. The buildings were erected through the dedication of faith-filled people who wished to celebrate their beliefs, and pass on a place of worship to future generations. Gifts such as these are not arbitrarily sold as a money generating proposition, though there have been occasions where declining attendance and escalating maintenance costs have forced such a situation.
People without an understanding of faith may not necessarily appreciate this intention of donors, and the subsequent obligation of recipients. They possibly look past the love and devotion of such generosity and see only commercial value, calculating the monetary opportunity of sale. It is perhaps difficult for them to understand the relationship of individual hearts with the Divine, and their dedication to furthering God’s work.
Finally, the newspaper article spoke of Brother Andre’s recent elevation to sainthood and criticized the ensuing celebration held in Montreal. Our modern era is in desperate need of worthy role models and true saints, and Brother Andre lived up to the mantle of both. When we discover such an individual, it is in everyone’s interest to raise their visibility for the young and hopefully still impressionable of society, to appreciate the good such individuals do in the course of a life of service.